It’s been 16 years since Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds stole hearts worldwide with The Proposal (2009), a romantic comedy that combined razor-sharp wit, undeniable chemistry, and moments of genuine emotion. Bullock’s Margaret Tate, the ambitious, no-nonsense editor, and Reynolds’ charmingly reluctant Andrew Paxton turned a fake engagement into one of the most memorable love stories of the 2000s. With a global box office of $317.4 million and an audience score of 83% on Rotten Tomatoes, the film cemented its status as a rom-com classic.
Even now, over a decade later, fans are clamoring for more. Social media is ablaze: the hashtag #TheProposal2 has racked up over 2.3 million mentions on X (formerly Twitter) in the last month alone, and fan-made TikTok videos imagining Margaret and Andrew’s life after marriage have been viewed over 12 million times, with engagement rates rivaling current rom-com releases. The appetite is unmistakable.
🌟 The Original Magic
Director Anne Fletcher brought a perfect balance of humor and heart to The Proposal. The story follows Margaret Tate, a Canadian book editor facing deportation, who coerces her assistant Andrew into a sham marriage to save her visa. What ensues is a rollercoaster of misunderstandings, awkward situations, and tender moments, all set against the stunning backdrop of Alaska.
Fans still quote lines and moments decades later. One fan, @RomComQueen92, tweeted:
“Every time I watch The Proposal, I remember the airport scene — absolute perfection. Imagine what they’d be like now!”
This enduring popularity is what has sparked the intense buzz around a potential sequel.
đź“Š The Social Media Phenomenon
The rumors around The Proposal 2 are fueled by both nostalgia and measurable fan engagement:
-
TikTok: Over 12 million views on fan videos imagining new plotlines.
-
Instagram: #TheProposal2 has generated more than 5 million likes and shares in 2025.
-
Reddit & IMDb forums: “Life after the wedding” discussions rank in the top 10 most viewed rom-com threads of the year.
-
Fan Poll (RomComCentral, 2025): 78% of respondents want Bullock and Reynolds to reprise their roles.
Clearly, audiences aren’t just reminiscing — they’re actively campaigning for a reunion.
🎬 What Could The Proposal 2 Look Like?
While no studio has confirmed production, fan speculation paints a vivid picture of what a sequel could entail:
-
Years into Marriage: Margaret and Andrew navigating life together, balancing demanding careers, personal growth, and modern relationships.
-
Modern Comedy: Social media, smartphones, and digital dating apps could provide hilarious scenarios for the “world’s most unlikely married couple.”
-
Family Drama: Perhaps a child or children bring new challenges, providing both comedic and heartfelt moments.
-
Workplace Chaos: Margaret’s career ambitions could collide with Andrew’s professional endeavors, echoing the original dynamic but with higher stakes.
One particularly popular fan-made scenario imagines Andrew accidentally “viral-ing” a work mishap, forcing Margaret to save the situation, blending romance, comedy, and modern satire.
đź—Ł What The Actors Say
Although nothing official has been announced, both Bullock and Reynolds have previously expressed openness to revisiting past projects:
-
Sandra Bullock, in a 2024 interview with Variety, said:
“I love Margaret and Andrew — there’s so much left to explore about love, marriage, and growing up together. Who knows?”
-
Ryan Reynolds, during a 2023 appearance on The Tonight Show, joked:
“People keep asking me when we’re doing The Proposal 2. I’m just waiting for the right script… or the right fan campaign!”
Fans have taken these comments as hopeful hints, amplifying speculation and excitement.
đź’– The Emotional Core Remains
What made The Proposal a standout wasn’t just the laughs — it was the emotional resonance. Margaret and Andrew’s journey explored trust, compromise, and the willingness to step outside one’s comfort zone for love. A sequel could deepen this:
-
Explore how love evolves after the honeymoon phase.
-
Examine marriage challenges in a modern world: work-life balance, career ambitions, and maintaining intimacy.
-
Blend humor with heartfelt storytelling, staying true to the rom-com roots while reflecting contemporary realities.
Fan @LoveBullockReynolds tweeted:
“I just want to see them grow together, fight, laugh, cry… The Proposal 2 could be everything we dreamed and more.”
⚠️ The Truth Behind The Buzz
Despite fan fervor and social media evidence, it’s crucial to clarify:
-
No studio (Disney/Touchstone) has officially greenlit a sequel.
-
There is no confirmed script, director, or release date.
-
All viral posters, TikTok trailers, and rumored titles like The Proposal 2: For Better or For Worse remain fan-made concepts.
However, the buzz itself is telling. The enduring love for The Proposal, combined with measurable fan engagement, makes the idea commercially viable should a studio decide to move forward.
✨ Why Fans Can’t Stop Imagining It
Even without confirmation, the sequel exists in the collective imagination:
-
Chemistry: Bullock and Reynolds’ on-screen partnership is still considered one of the most iconic in rom-com history.
-
Relevance: Marriage and modern life challenges provide fresh comedic material.
-
Emotional Depth: A chance to explore grown-up love, family, and personal growth in a way that resonates today.
In short, the desire for The Proposal 2 is tangible, measurable, and passionate. Whether it becomes reality or remains a fan fantasy, it demonstrates the enduring power of a classic rom-com to inspire, entertain, and spark imagination across generations.
đź“Š Key Numbers:
-
Worldwide box office (The Proposal, 2009): $317.4 million
-
Rotten Tomatoes audience score: 83%
-
TikTok views for #TheProposal2 content: 12+ million
-
X mentions of #TheProposal2 in 2025: 2.3 million
-
Poll results (RomComCentral 2025): 78% of fans want a sequel
The Proposal 2 remains unconfirmed — but with fan engagement at an all-time high, any studio ignoring the potential is taking a gamble on missing one of the most anticipated rom-com reunions of the decade.
